Syria: Another Unending Imperialist Agony

An Imperialist Turning Point?

There has been much agonising in the various imperialist camps in the last couple of weeks. A lost vote in the British Parliament by the Con-Dem coalition, a retreat from instant retaliation by the White House to await the return of Congress, the Pope backing non-intervention and even Putin saying that he had cut spare parts supplies for the S-300 anti-missile missile system to the Assad regime, all show an unusual degree of confusion amongst the masters of the universe. None of this agonising compares with the agony that the population of Syria has already had to undergo for more than two and a half years. Over 100,000 have died and more than 6 million have become refugees with 2 million of them in official UN camps in Turkey, Jordan, Iraq and Lebanon. This is what makes Obama’s “red line” of the use of poison gas all the more arbitrary. According to the current information a maximum of 1400 people died (the most authenticated say about 400) in this horrible manner. However these figures are miniscule in relation to the humanitarian crisis that has engulfed Syria since March 2011.

And let us not be taken in by the supposed “humanitarian motives” of those calling for strikes against the Assad regime. The US, being the only power so far to devastate whole cities with nuclear bombs, was no stranger to chemical warfare in Vietnam (where napalm and Agent Orange have still left their mark). More recently the US connived at Saddam Hussein’s use of sarin gas against Iranian conscripts by warning Saddam of an impending attack. The Pentagon knew they were aiding and abetting a gas attack against the Iranians. As one US military man said “he did not need to tell us he would use gas. We already knew”. [See http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2013/08/25/secret_cia_files_prove… for the full story.]

In Britain the situation is a bit more complicated since the shadow of the lies that Blair told to get a vote for war in Iraq looms heavily over the discredited political system. In the face of the biggest mass protest ever seen in the UK (15 Feb 2003) the House of Commons bought Blair’s “dodgy dossier” that claimed that Saddam Hussein had “weapons of mass destruction” and voted for war. Not only were no such weapons found but the fallout from the war in terms of chaos in the Middle East and increased terrorist attacks in the UK have made many of our ruling class aware of the consequences of getting involved in Syria. Touchingly the Stop the War types are modestly taking the credit for the rejection of Cameron’s motion for war but in fact most MPs based their vote on soundings they had done in their own constituencies – there was even less support for a Syrian attack than the Iraq and Afghanistan adventures. Even ex-General (now Baron) Richard Dannatt (former Tory adviser on military matters) came out against the war on the grounds that we should not send “our troops” to places where the UK population would not give them any credit.

The Widening Conflict

No, the motive for hesitation in Western ruling class circles is the old one. How to make a precise calculation of their wider interests? Over Afghanistan and Iraq it was much clearer. That was not only about trying to rid a “nest of vipers” in Afghanistan (whose eggs had been hatched by the CIA in the anti-USSR war) but also retain control of the oil market and thus maintain the dollar as the dominant global currency. (See our analysis in http://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2003-03-01/iraq-war-and-imperialist-… but there are many more). Whilst the USA (and its ally Israel) was quite happy to see the Assad regime in retreat from Lebanon (where it still acts as a conduit for Iranian aid to reach Hezbollah) and even see the overthrow of the Damascus government, the prospect of more chaos and another staging post for Islamic fundamentalism emerging have given it pause for thought. Bush’s oil wars (nor the intervention in Libya for that matter since the state has since virtually collapsed) did not have the outcomes that US imperialism needed and putting US boots on the ground in any area is considered now to be a dangerous and possibly counter-productive ploy (despite the fact that US casualties have been relatively small – less than the number who have died by suicide and in accidents). This dilemma has partly fuelled the debate inside the US ruling class. Whilst the Obama regime has for two years taken “the Metternich position” on Syria, i.e. ignore the escalating violence and “let it burn itself out beyond the pale of human civilisation”, others (including former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, head of the CIA Petraeus and Defense Secretary Panetta) argued that allowing Qatar and Saudi Arabia to arm the Islamic groups meant that whatever the outcome of the fighting some form of anti-American Islamist regime would emerge. In deference to this Obama agreed to send small arms to the more secular opposition forces but, again underlying the current paralysis, none have yet arrived. Obama’s off the cuff electoral promise last year that if Assad used chemical weapons it would be a “red line” issue was intended to appease his critics at home and give Assad a warning. It then came back to haunt him when his new Secretary of State, John Kerry, announced that the US had credible intelligence that sarin gas had been used by the Assad Government on 21 August. Kerry, who sprang to fame in 1971 as a “veteran” who testified before Congress to the rape, murder and mutilation of civilians in Vietnam by the US Army, and called for US withdrawal because there was nothing in Vietnam that threatened US’ vital interests, is now the head of the warmongering camp. Obama’s get out strategy has been to put the issue to a Congress which was not even sitting at the time. Whilst Cameron ineptly rushed to steamroller a resolution for action through the House of Commons (and humiliatingly lost) Obama has prevaricated once again on the action so many of his own party are calling for. For decades US Presidents have been wresting the right to declare war without Congressional approval but now Obama finds it useful to hand that responsibility back. The divisions in US ruling class opinion run deep. The hawks keep on saying how the real question is the “red line” about Iran obtaining nuclear weapons and that if no action is taken now it will reveal US impotence or, as they put it, undermine its “credibility”. Ominously their speeches end with the assertion that they are 100% behind Israel.

Israel for its part would have been quite happy if the Arab Spring had not happened. After all, the result of all their wars since 1948 was to surround themselves with Arab dictators who in one way or another would do business with them or, at least like Syria, not dare to confront them head on. But the fall of Mubarak and the active engagement of the reactionary monarchies of the Arabian peninsula and Gulf in assisting various Islamist anti-Israel groups has widened the circle of Israel’s enemies. At the moment they are too weak and too divided to be a big threat but the situation is being watched closely by Israeli intelligence. Israel was not slow to act when it came to Hezbollah’s intervention in Syria and has now bombed Syrian soil several times against the Hezbollah forces.

And then there is Turkey. Erdogan has been excoriating the West for both its failure to act against Assad and its acquiescence in the removal of the democratically-elected Islamist Morsi in Egypt [See http://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2013-08-31/the-continuing-crisis-in-…]. At first his rhetoric was quite useful to divert attention from his own little local difficulty with protestors over the AK party’s creeping islamisation of the country. However there are also real material problems for a Turkish economy which saw its GDP drop into recession in 2009. This has now recovered but only due to deficit financing which means, according to the Economist [http://www.economist.com/node/21552216], “Turkey's deficit measured in dollars is second only to America's.” With the lira plunging 10% and capital fleeing the country Turkey is now facing more difficult terms for the loans the AK party have used to fund a building boom. On top of this the growing number of Syrian refugees and the fact that Turkish lorries cannot now get south as the border with Syria is closed (they are now taken in their hundreds by ship to Israel) is a further economic blow to the Turkish state. Small wonder he wants something done to get the war finished as soon as possible (and a bit of tough (if impotent) rhetoric will go down well with his voters as an election approaches).

The most consistent imperialists in all this have been Russia, China and Iran. Although they are increasingly worried by Assad’s handling of events they have not deviated from support for his regime. Iran has sent advisers (and it is reported troops) who seem to have put some backbone into the previously retreating forces of the regime. China has refused to sanction any intervention in Syria in keeping with its international policy of non-interference and not passing judgements on the records of other regimes (a current plus for Chinese advances amongst African states). For Russia the stakes are higher since Syria represents the last sovereign state which it can count on as an ally in the Middle East. Russia still has bases there including its largest naval base outside home waters and the total collapse of the Assad regime would be an enormous blow both strategically and materially. The Russians learned the lesson of Libya where they failed to prevent the imposition of a no-fly resolution in Libya thus sealing the fate of Ghaddafi. If the US does start air strikes expect the Russians to step up supplies of S-300 missiles. Putin offered to stop sending parts for them to Assad as an opener for some kind of negotiated political settlement but the US refused to take what they saw as a poisoned chalice and so we can expect Russian support for Assad to remain strong. Their final master stroke on the international chessboard has been to take up Kerry’s ill-thought out challenge for Syria to hand over all its chemical weapons. This proposal could delay US action for months and may even stalemate it altogether. This is not a given as it also affects Russia’s relations with Syria. The Syrians have agreed to the Russian proposal only if the US withdraws its threat to carry out air strikes (which Putin has been happy to accept). The Syrian regime has never admitted to having chemical weapons (which it holds in case it need to retaliate against the Israelis equally undeclared nuclear weapons) and Assad continues to repeat his threat that if the US attacks over the poison gas issue then his “allies” will wreak unspecified revenge on the US somewhere in the world. In this context getting a UN resolution to include both a chemical weapons ban and the threat of air strikes is unlikely and after a bit of time they can all get back to square one.

No War But the Class War

Already we have seen the war spill over into Lebanon and involve Iranian forces directly. Turkey too has not only been drawn in as it is used as a base by anti-Assad fighters hiding amongst the refugees. As we write US aircraft carriers and a Russian flotilla are closing in on the Eastern Mediterranean. Despite the Commons vote UK fighter bombers have been despatched to Cyprus and in next-door Jordan (where nearly 20% of the population are now Syrian refugees) 1000 US troops, F-16 fighters and Patriot missiles are already assembled after a recent military exercise. All of this outside interference underlines the fact that we are not talking about the Syrian “Civil War” which the news media so often refer to but about the latest cockpit in which imperialist antagonisms are being fought out, if only by proxy. In a sane world everyone would see that no-one can win here. Any impartial observer can see that without an end to the carnage another 100,000 will die for nothing and the danger of the Syrian conflict becoming a wider one is increasing weekly. The fact is though we don’t live in anything like a sane or impartial world but one dominated by capitalist imperialist motives.

In this situation the proletariat in Syria can do or say nothing. It has already been ideologically and materially dismembered by either falling into line to defend one of the competing forces or it has simply become victim of the conflict. It cannot even get direct help from the international working class. Modern warfare does not directly engage the working class as it did in previous wars even up to Vietnam. Armies in the leading capitalist states are no longer conscript armies, weapons are stockpiled years in advance. Even the unprecedented international demonstrations which engulfed the Western world in 2003 to oppose the attack on Iraq were ignored by a political system which is only superficially representative and democratic. Modern wars are more like the ones described in Orwell’s 1984. They are fought a long way away and don’t materially have an impact on most people in the leading imperialist states.

But the new social media mean that the world is becoming a smaller place. Opposing these wars without giving support to brutal regimes like that of Assad is the start of opposing the system that survives by them. The more our rulers ignore opposition to war the more they discredit themselves and their system. The smarter elements of the world’s ruling class know this and this partially explains their hesitations today. But the bestial appetites of capitalist imperialism won’t hold back for long. Whether in Syria or Mali or the Congo the struggle for the planet’s resources will break out anew. For the international working class there is nothing here to support (not even the supposed “revolution” which started the anti-Assad struggle over 2 years ago). Our position remains the same as ever. The only war we support is the class war to destroy this system of global carnage once and for all. Fighting against austerity or whatever else capitalism tries to impose on us is a first act in rejecting this system. Currently the world proletariat is out of the game and we can only get back into it by fighting for our own interests on our own terms. In the final analysis it is only when workers in the world’s most powerful states have paralysed the ability of imperialism to interfere where it wants will we take a real step forward on the road to human liberation.

-- Jock, 10 September 2013