(The following article has been written by a CWO sympathiser. We publish it as a contribution to the discussion of the problem of transphobia from a class perspective.(1))
Gender, Rights, and Marxism
Following the April 2025 Supreme Court Ruling, which declared that the terms “woman” and “sex” refer exclusively to biological sex at birth, the last 18 months have ushered in repeated “lawfare” measures against the UK’s transgender population.(2) As a result, many on the liberal and reformist left have taken to decrying legal discrimination as the act or whim of a shadowy spectre haunting the queer community (namely TERFs and morally bankrupt politicians). What this convenient and simple narrative of the evils of “gender critical” activism misses, however, is an understanding of how and why capitalism structures and informs human behaviour at every level. No attention is paid to the specific ways in which capitalism reduces entire social groups down to a flattened binary, such as cisgender or transgender, conferring different rights on that basis accordingly.
This differentiation between individuals is inherent to the system’s logic, and is why any discussion on trans rights following the recent wave of legal proscriptions must be situated in a historical materialist analysis. We frequently hear talk of the need to guarantee equality and, especially for our purposes here, rights for the trans population, on the basis that this may end discrimination and prejudice. However, Marx saw through this alluring piece of bourgeois ideology in his 1844 essay _On the Jewish Question_:
"The state in its own way abolishes distinctions based on birth, rank, education and occupation when it declares birth, rank, education and occupation to be non-political distinctions, when it proclaims that every member of the people is an equal participant in popular sovereignty regardless of these distinctions, when it treats all those elements which go to make up the actual life of the people from the standpoint of the state. Nevertheless the state allows private property, education and occupation to act and assert their particular nature in their own way, i.e., as private property, as education and as occupation. Far from abolishing these factual distinctions, the state presupposes them in order to exist, it only experiences itself as a political state and asserts its universality in opposition to these elements … Where the political state has attained its full degree of development man leads a double life … He lives in the political community, where he regards himself as a communal being, and in civil society, where he is active as a private individual, regards other men as means, debases himself to a means and becomes a plaything of alien powers.(3)"
Rights therefore do not and cannot liberate any group. Equal pay for women did not abolish patriarchy, just as same-sex marriage did not abolish homophobia. While, of course, the arguments proposed are far more extensive than these, we reduce them to these basic demands to illustrate the core issue with reformism: rather than challenging the category itself, reformists accept its frameworks and logics, fighting an endless battle on that basis. After all, “to be radical is to grasp things by the root”.(4)
EHRC Code of Practice: A Legal Cataclysm
The EHRC, in all its legal and logistical contradictions, is the prime example of a capitalist machine struggling to categorise groups within society neatly. The EHRC, on its face, has declared the inalienability of biological sex, in claiming that biological sex is inviolable and must be abided by in all cases. Confusingly, the guidelines do still technically respect and acknowledge the existing protections trans people have, specifically with Gender Recognition Certificates (GRCs). As per the UN:
"...provisions within the Equality Act, which continues to prohibit discrimination based on gender reassignment, sex and perceived sex and the Gender Recognition Act 2004 that protect the rights of transgender persons remain valid, including that individuals with a gender recognition certificate must be treated “for all purposes” as their acquired gender…The judgment does not remove the legal protections trans people currently enjoy under the Equality Act, the experts said. But it may be used to justify exclusionary policies that further stigmatise and marginalise an already vulnerable population.(5)"
What this means is those with GRCs are still recognised to be living as their “acquired gender”, which extends to pensions, marriage certificates, birth certificates, and other relevant legislation.(6) This has not changed since the 2004 Gender Recognition Act.(7) Nevertheless, the state has still stripped back trans rights from the 2010 Equality Act, as the GRC is now considered insufficient for accessing single-sex hospital wards, toilets, etc.(8) The guidelines are a logistical nightmare, not least because asking proof of biological sex opens up any business or organisation to harassment or discrimination cases, and thus the enforcement of such policies is difficult at best and impossible at worst.(9) The policing of gender identity is now an institutionalised reality of law, and will impact every trans or cis individual that does not conform to strict binary expressions.
Rights, Access, and Reality
Whilst the talk of hypothetical legal access to these spaces has been openly bandied about in the media, particular attention must be drawn to the specific circumstances trans people experience. Those trans people with the financial means to do so are hypothetically capable of mounting legal challenges to expose the absurdity of these new guidelines, which preserve their protected characteristic of gender reassignment under the Equality Act, but we must be realistic.(10) Trans people are disproportionately more likely to be pressured into poverty,(11) homelessness,(12) unemployment,(13) and drug addiction(14) compared with the general population. The ability for a vulnerable chronically unemployed individual to safeguard their own rights is next to zero, and an entirely liberal fabrication of reality which serves only to mystify the relations of capitalism. The experiences of trans people facing systematic, sustained, and repeated segregation is impossible to ignore – the new guidelines only expose the contradictions of our legal system at their most absurd.
The chasm between right of access and reality is well demonstrated by spaces such as domestic abuse refuges – although most have trans-inclusive policies, something which the new ruling now complicates(15), previously the norm was self-exclusion, as trans people presented with the option of a woman’s or man’s refuge may find neither option preferable – they may be too masculine for a women’s shelter and considered to cause women to feel unsafe, or too feminine to feel safe in a man’s shelter.(16) Many would rather choose homelessness to avoid constant surveillance, questioning, or further risk of abuse from social workers or in shared hostel spaces.(17) To further compound this delicate and invisible form of structural discrimination, the state’s new guidelines have thus made it even harder for trans people to access lifesaving support and care.
Moreover, whilst some may see the current EHRC code of practice as a new and unprecedented act of violence, the guidelines are in fact nothing more than the crystallised embodiment of a decades-long process of the decline of social services. Access to healthcare, according to the British Medical Journal (2025), has become something of a sick joke for trans people: the average waiting time for a first appointment at a Gender Identity Clinic is now 5 years and 7 months.(18) NHS Wales’ recent decision to pause all gender affirming surgeries, on the flimsy and meaningless evidence that an above-average number of referrals have taken place compared with the rest of the UK, has pushed upwards of a thousand patients into a state of limbo and misery.(19)
In addition to the systematic discrimination of trans workers,(20) the fact that medical avenues to relieve the suffering caused by gender incongruence are being routinely denied through an impenetrable fortresses of bureaucracy, helps to explain why trans people have some of the highest suicide rates per capita in the country.(21)
Ideological and Class-Driven Witch-Hunts
Decades of privatisation, labour market restructuring, and seemingly endless economic crisis has ripped apart the UK’s social fabric. The abject misery of the proletariat, mired in the bleeding belly of a capitalist machine that has long outlived its sell-by date, continues to grow. Betrayed again and again by reformist politicians, workers have begun to look inwards amongst their ranks, spurred on by the ruling class – the bourgeoisie – that has no solution to these endless crises but to manufacture dissent through culture wars. As Marx wrote in 1845:
"The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas, i.e. the class which is the ruling material force of society, is at the same time its ruling intellectual force. The class which has the means of material production at its disposal, has control at the same time over the means of mental production, so that thereby, generally speaking, the ideas of those who lack the means of mental production are subject to it. The ruling ideas are nothing more than the ideal expression of the dominant material relationships, the dominant material relationships grasped as ideas; hence of the relationships which make the one class the ruling one, therefore, the ideas of its dominance.(22)"
Insofar as we can trace the genesis of this recent moral panic surrounding “gender ideology”, Marx’s words ring just as true now as then. For example, a report from Amnesty International (2026) shows that, since 2010, four of the largest UK newspapers publish a combined 9 articles per day on “trans issues”, with overwhelmingly negative language used.(23) Trans people are relegated to a subject of scandal, treated as a spectacle of the taboo and degenerate when reported on, but otherwise entirely invisible.(24) 48 new “gender critical” organisations have been formed since 2017, a staggering rise bankrolled by resourceful figures like billionaire and resident “trans-exclusionary radical feminist” J.K. Rowling.(25) The rise in hate crimes and increasing hostility of public attitudes show the sinister beauty of this age-old tactic of the bourgeoisie.(26) And, of course, let’s not forget the influence of religious conservatism which, in its quest to restore a patriarchal status quo, serves as a major driver of all kinds of gender hysteria across the world (not just in the West).
The aim of this witch-hunt, as with the smear campaign against the gay community during the AIDS pandemic, is to find a convenient scapegoat for the system to cover its sins. The mapping of all societal ills onto one minority group or another, whether it be refugees, queer people, or Muslims, is precisely designed as a tactic of division. The escalation of lawfare against the trans community is motivated entirely by the interests of the most reactionary sections of the bourgeoisie. Ostensibly, also, these tactics obscure class distinctions in favour of identity-based categories, which only further complicate the issue. They draw the proletariat into fighting amongst itself. They also frame entire groups as homogenous: the class interests of a trans worker and a trans bourgeois are treated as the same, and alliances are erected on this basis. This is a sentiment we must firmly reject. More on this later.
Capitalist Categories, And Why Reformism Won’t Free Us
Capitalism as a system always seeks to categorise and divide society into neat identifiable groups. Under a class society, the distinction drawn between those who own the means of production and those who do not, is the most obvious. But this extends further, with the institutions of race, gender, sexuality, ability, citizenship, and so on. The endless squabbling, division, re-division, construction and reconstruction of these categories is inherent to the logic of a system which views the individual as the cornerstone of all social existence. From assigning sex at birth based on observable secondary sexual characteristics, to judging ethnicity on the basis of skin colour, all the way to deciding who can access public funds or gainful employment in accordance with the passport or visa held, the capitalist machine has always divided the population. Therefore, it should come as no surprise that trans people's existence is being questioned and debated, with their position in such rigid gender binaries standing as an essential and irreducible aspect of capitalist ideology. The proposed integration and assimilation advocated for by many on the liberal reformist left, such as making GRCs easier to obtain or undoing the EHRC guidelines, will not, and – this must be made absolutely clear – cannot end the structural basis for this social divide.
We draw particular focus to the inherent unworkability of reformism for the simple reason that we have been here before. The Greens oppose the EHRC Code of Practice and support self-ID, for example, and many on the left view this party as the vehicle for ending this decade of humiliation for trans people. But, we ask, have they already forgotten the case of Theresa May? Have they forgotten how less than a decade ago the Prime Minister of the notoriously socially reactionary Conservatives stated:
"We are determined to eradicate homophobic and transphobic bullying. We have laid out plans to reform the gender recognition act, streamlining and demedicalising the process for changing gender because being trans is not an illness and it should not be treated as such.(27)"
Regardless of whether these fine sentiments amounted to anything – and to be clear, they did not! – this simple piece of evidence should illustrate to any serious radical worth their salt that the bourgeoisie are as fickle as sand. The tide of public opinion carries with it a shifting foundation of law and morals. From 2017, when that speech was made, to now, we have seen 5 different Prime Ministers, all of whom have in various ways employed trans issues as an asset in the culture war. Any attempt to rely on reformism to liberate the trans community must also concede that positive changes can be undone whenever they become politically inconvenient. Expecting any different outcome from the Greens is naive at best and dangerous at worst. This is because only a revolutionary change in the entire way we organise society on every level of economics and politics can liberate queer people from oppression.
Class Struggle and the Self-Emancipation of the Entire Proletariat
The oppression of all peoples will never be resolved through appeals to the legal system, as many charlatan reformists such as the Greens have pledged to do.(28) It is this recognition which must be communicated, not only to transgender proletarians currently mystified by the illusions of reformist gradualism, but to all sections of the working class. The most class conscious and revolutionary strata of the working class must work to draw all proletarians away from the honeypot of the progressive sections of the bourgeoisie, uniting our struggles with a shared class solidarity, going beyond these sectarian, identitarian politics.
The proletariat must stand united against the barbarism of this system that cares only for exploitation and profits. We have far more in common that unites us rather than divides us. This commonality is class, and it is on this basis that we must fight for true liberation. This means, for example, linking the issue of poor access to health services, to housing, and to refuges among trans people to the general crisis of the NHS, the decline of social housing and cuts to refuge provision, issues which affect all working class people. Ultimately, the fight for a classless, moneyless, stateless society is the only way of destroying antagonisms between individuals, of sublating these categories of division and difference, and replacing them with the free association of producers based on needs and not profits.
The search for true equality must be undertaken by the workers themselves. We must not hand our struggle over to parliament, to MPs who only care for their careers or union leaders that seek to mediate our grievances to keep the system limping along. The only way we can do this, as history teaches us, is through the construction of a communist party. This party must stand for the self-activity and self-emancipation of the working class. It must be aligned with the principles of the abolition of capitalism, the state, money, classes, and, ultimately, itself, through the revolutionary dictatorship of the proletariat. We do not claim to be this party, but we work towards its construction.
The lesson that the proletariat, regardless of their identity label, must learn is this: appealing to the state to free us on our behalf will only lead to more failure; it is up to us as workers to win this struggle.
-- Dolphin _
October 2026
Notes:
Image: David.Monniaux (CC BY 4.0), https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Transgender_symbol_%E2%9A%A7_on…
(1) For previous articles related to this subject, see also _Marxism and Sexuality_ (https://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2020-05-09/marxism-and-sexuality), _Class Struggle and Gender Trouble_ (https://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2021-04-19/class-struggle-and-gende…), _The American Ideology: Intersectionality Against the Working Class_ (https://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2026-03-23/the-american-ideology-in…), or _Beyond Bourgeois Legality: India's Transgender Amendment Bill_ (https://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2026-03-24/beyond-bourgeois-legalit…).
(2) House of Commons Library (2026) ‘Supreme Court judgment on the meaning of “sex” in the Equality Act 2010: For Women Scotland’. UK Parliament. Available at: https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-10259/
(3) Marx, K. (1992) ‘On the Jewish Question’, pp. 219-220, _Karl Marx: Early Writings_. 1st edn. United Kingdom: Penguin Books Ltd.
(4) Marx, K. (1992) ‘Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right. Introduction’, p. 251, _Karl Marx: Early Writings_. 1st edn. United Kingdom: Penguin Books Ltd.
(5) _UN experts warn of legal uncertainty and rights implications following UK Supreme Court ruling_ (2026) OHCHR. Available at: https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2025/05/un-experts-warn-legal-u…
(6) _Gender Recognition Act 2004_. Stonewall UK. Available at: https://www.stonewall.org.uk/resources/lgbtq-hubs/trans-hub/gender-reco…
(7) Ibid.
(8) _Updated EHRC services code of practice to take ef ect on 5 August 2026_ (2026) Dentons. Available at: https://www.dentons.com/en/insights/articles/2026/july/28/updated-ehrc-…
(9) Ibid.
(10) Ibid.
(11) McKechnie, D.G.J. et al. (2023) ‘Transgender identity in young people and adults recorded in UK primary care electronic patient records: retrospective, dynamic, cohort study’, _BMJ Medicine_, 2(1), p. e000499. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjmed-2023-000499
(12) GOV.UK (2024) _Lesbian, gay, bisexual and Transgender people’s experiences of homelessness_ (2024). Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/lgbt-peoples-experiences-of-…
(13) Office for National Statistics (2021) _Census 2021 gender identity estimates for England and Wales, additional guidance on uncertainty and appropriate use (2025) Census 2021 gender identity estimates for England and Wales, additional guidance on uncertainty and appropriate use_. Available at: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/culturalidentity/ge…
(14) Collyer, A. (2025) _Understanding the prevalence of drug use in the LGBTQ+ community - UK Addiction Treatment Centres_. https://www.ukat.co.uk/blog/society/understanding-the-prevalence-of-dru…
(15) Brooks, L. (2025) _‘Trans women have never felt like a threat’: women’s refuges grapple with supreme court ruling_. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2025/may/02/uk-gender-ruling-ignite…
(16) Faye, S. (2022) _The Transgender Issue: An Argument for Justice_. 1st edn. New York: Verso, pp. 52-68.
(17) Ibid., pp. 52-68.
(18) O’Dowd, A. (2025) ‘“Unacceptable” waits and lack of safety data at adult gender clinics in England, review finds’, _BMJ_, 391, p. r2667. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.r2667
(19) Parsons, L. (2026) _“Devastated”: Up to 800 Trans+ patients affected by Welsh Gender Service surgery cancellations._ https://www.wearequeeraf.com/devastated-up-to-800-trans-patients-affect…
(20) Roache, Q. (2024) _Bullying, harassment and discrimination of LGBT people in the workplace_. Research and Reports. TUC, pp. 12–27.
(21) Hutt-Dixon, T. (2026) ‘Trans people in UK dying by suicide at higher rates than any other demographic’, _Pink News_, 28 April. Available at: https://www.thepinknews.com/2026/04/28/uk-trans-suicide/
(22) Marx, K. and Engels, F. (1974) _The German Ideology_, p. 64. 2nd edn. Edited by C.J. Arthur. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
(23) Amnesty International (2026) _Like a snowball: the growth and impact of the gender critical movement in the UK_, pp. 9-10. Available at: https://likeasnowball.co.uk/
(24) Ibid. p. 11
(25) Ibid. pp. 11, 19-20.
(26) Ibid. p. 21.
(27) Mason, R. (2017). _Theresa May Plans to Let People Change Gender without Medical Checks_. [online] The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/oct/18/theresa-may-plans-to-le…
(28) Harker, M. (2026) ‘Statement on the latest EHRC Code of Practice’, _LGBTIQA+ Greens_, 22 May 2026. Available at: https://lgbtiqa.greenparty.org.uk/2026/05/22/statement-on-the-latest-eh…
